Speaker Stephanie Thompson sitting with laptop with title: The Biggest Lie I Believed About Brand Partnerships

The Biggest Lie I Believed About Brand Partnerships

May 27, 20253 min read

The Biggest Lie I Believed About Brand Partnerships

For a long time, I believed creators should feel lucky when a brand said yes.

I thought the creator’s role was to over-deliver, stay grateful, and not question the terms.

That belief shaped how I approached partnerships early on—and it created an unspoken power imbalance. The brand had the leverage. The creator just had to perform.

What I’ve learned after years working with both creators and brands is this:
That mindset kills long-term value.


The Turning Point

Everything changed when I began to see what truly aligned partnerships could become—especially when a creator brings a community-first audience that is trusted, engaged, and primed to take action.

The creator isn’t just delivering impressions.
They’re delivering trust. And that has compounding value when the brand shows up as an actual partner, not just a sponsor.

Here’s what that looks like.


Partnerships That Work: Real Examples

1. From Podcast Ad to Keynote Stage

A brand initially approached a creator to discuss a standard podcast integration and social post package.

But through deeper conversation, it became clear the creator was also a seasoned speaker—and the brand happened to be looking for a keynote presenter for an upcoming event.

What began as a digital activation turned into an in-person opportunity. The brand didn’t just buy exposure—they extended the relationship into real-world visibility and influence.

2. Book Reprint with Brand Alignment

Another creator needed support republishing a sold-out book.
The brand didn’t just offer funding—they asked to include a one-page letter from their leadership team, sharing why supporting the creator’s work mattered to them.

That small gesture transformed the partnership from a transaction into a shared narrative.


The Shift in Thinking

The most impactful partnerships we’ve seen at PodXL are rarely built on downloads, impressions, or traditional media KPIs.

They're built on:

  • Shared values

  • Creative alignment

  • Willingness to explore how a partnership can evolve over time

When brands invest just a small paid media budget into repurposing the creator’s content—or amplify it through their own channels—we’ve seen the return multiply significantly.

Sometimes it’s 4x. Sometimes more.
But it’s rarely obvious in a basic spreadsheet.


Not All ROI Is Measurable—And That’s the Point

This is where many brands hesitate. They want performance data that mirrors Facebook ads or short-term campaign results.

But podcast and creator partnerships don’t operate on the same timelines—or rules.

They build over time. And when done well, they deliver:

  • Deeper audience connection

  • Stronger brand affinity

  • Long-term market trust


What I Know Now

  • Creators bring more than content. They bring credibility.

  • Brands have more to offer than budget. They have reach, infrastructure, and shared values—if they choose to engage them.

  • The best partnerships don’t feel like transactions. They feel like aligned momentum.

If your goal is short-term clicks, partnerships may not be the right strategy.
But if you’re building something with depth, resonance, and staying power—this is where real value lives.

If you're ready to find out if you're ready for a partnership or want to build out your company's brand partnership strategy connect: [email protected]

Back to Blog

© Copyright 2025. Podcast Expert Lab. All Rights Reserved.